Judge denies exclusion of some evidence in Garza murder case

BROOKLYN - A judge today ruled that a statement made to police by the registered sex offender accused of killing an aspiring Brooklyn dancer can be heard in court, while another comment will not be allowed. Newburgh Detective Doug Scott said he was booking Michael Mele on an unrelated charge - and hadbeen told by defense lawyers not to question Mele - when he saw aninjured finger. He said he told another officer, "Looks like he'sgot a bite mark" and Mele responded that "he had injured himselfwith a small knife at his work."Then Scott said he saw the scratches and said, "You're allscratched up," to which Mele said that his cat scratched him.Orange County Judge Nicholas DeRosa ruled that Mele's commentabout the knife is admissible because it was a spontaneousstatement and not the result of illegal police questioning. But hesaid Scott should have realized after the knife comment that hismention of the scratches might elicit a response from Mele andtherefore ruled that the cat response was inadmissible.

Mele has pleaded not guilty to murder, manslaughter and evidence tampering in the death of 25-year-old Laura Garza.

Garza disappeared in Dec. 2008 five months after she moved to Brooklyn from McAllen, Texas. Police say she was last seen with Mele. Her body was found in Pennsylvania in April 2010.AP wire services contributed to this report

Sex offender pleads not guilty in Laura Garza's death Loved ones remember Laura Garza on 2nd anniversary of disappearance

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Trending Video

News 12 Brooklyn hit the streets to ask 1 Word on the Street: GPS devices
2 VIDEO: Brooklyn Botanic Garden to host annual Sakura Matsuri Festival
Sea Cliff's Troy Ramey was voted off 'The 3 Elisa's Entertainment for 4/26
News 12 Long Island has won the regional 4 News 12 Long Island wins regional Edward R. Murrow Award
At least six people have been arrested and 5 Six arrested, 4 more sought in Coney Island gang assault video

advertisement | advertise on News 12


Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.