‘He stuffed a scarf down her throat’ – Trial begins for man accused of killing childhood friend

The trial has begun for a Monmouth County man accused of strangling a former high school classmate during a robbery and throwing her body into the Shark River.

News 12 Staff

Jan 23, 2019, 1:45 PM

Updated 1,912 days ago

Share:

The trial has begun for a Monmouth County man accused of strangling a former high school classmate during a robbery and throwing her body into the Shark River.
Monmouth County prosecutors said Wednesday that Liam McAtasney thought he was going to get $100,000 from the robbery but only got $8,000. They also say he confessed to the killing of Sarah Stern in a conversation recorded by a friend who was working with investigators.
"Sarah Stern will not be walking through those doors into this courtroom at any point. She will never send her father another text. She will never hug him, or tell him she loves him,” said Assistant Prosecutor Meghan Doyle.
McAtasney’s friend and roommate Preston Taylor has pleaded guilty for his role in the murder. He admitted to helping McAtasney allegedly throw Stern’s body off the Route 35 Bridge into the river. He is considered to be the prosecution’s star witness.
"You don't have to like him to believe him. You don't have to like him to think he's credible," Doyle told the jury.
Taylor described how he and McAtasney plotted the murder. He said that McAtasney said that the money Stern had inherited from her deceased mother was “enough to kill for.”
McAtasney, Taylor and Stern were all former high school classmates and childhood friends. Taylor and Stern were each other’s dates to the junior prom several years earlier.
"This is a girl we talked about robbing and killing and she was in our house, having a conversation. The whole thing just awkward,” Taylor testified.
Taylor also described how McAtasney allegedly killed Stern once he had her alone.
“He went into detail about how he killed her. Said that he strangled her. That it took quite a while for her to actually stop breathing - about a half-hour. And in the process, she peed herself, she vomited. When she started throwing up he stuffed a scarf down her throat. She said his name a couple times,” Taylor said.
Defense attorney Carlos Diaz Cobo says that McAtasney made up the entire story because he wanted to impress a friend who was an experienced horror movie maker.
Cobo is expected to cross-examine Taylor Thursday morning.
McAtasney faces life in prison. Taylor will likely receive a sentence of up to 20 years when he is sentenced after the trial.
Stern went missing in December, 2016. Her body has never been found.
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.
 


More from News 12
2:04
Health care workers, community hold prayer to call for SUNY Downstate to stay open

Health care workers, community hold prayer to call for SUNY Downstate to stay open

1:47
Brooklyn students present their social justice solutions on varying issues in national competition

Brooklyn students present their social justice solutions on varying issues in national competition

2:08
Early-morning patchy fog, cool and cloudy weather for Friday

Early-morning patchy fog, cool and cloudy weather for Friday

1:46
Vendors rally to demand accessible vendor licenses and permits after DSNY crackdowns

Vendors rally to demand accessible vendor licenses and permits after DSNY crackdowns

2:11
Bronx Zoo celebrates 125 years of bringing joy to New Yorkers

Bronx Zoo celebrates 125 years of bringing joy to New Yorkers

2:05
Police: 2 men wanted for stealing $2,000 from Bay Ridge store at gunpoint

Police: 2 men wanted for stealing $2,000 from Bay Ridge store at gunpoint

1:58
Explore the seasonal flora and fauna unique to Prospect Park in Brooklyn

Explore the seasonal flora and fauna unique to Prospect Park in Brooklyn

0:25
Police: Person of interest in custody following bomb squad investigation in Midwood

Police: Person of interest in custody following bomb squad investigation in Midwood

1:44
Dyker Heights elementary school students send letters and care packages to at-risk military veterans

Dyker Heights elementary school students send letters and care packages to at-risk military veterans

0:24
NYPD: Man walks into East Flatbush hospital, dies from gunshot wounds

NYPD: Man walks into East Flatbush hospital, dies from gunshot wounds

0:23
Man hospitalized following brutal stabbing in Brownsville, police say

Man hospitalized following brutal stabbing in Brownsville, police say

0:23
Spring Arrival: Hummingbirds heading to New York

Spring Arrival: Hummingbirds heading to New York

1:34
NYPD says new campaign has lowered crime citywide; some New Yorkers don’t buy it

NYPD says new campaign has lowered crime citywide; some New Yorkers don’t buy it

2:18
Landlord battling pancreatic cancer fighting to evict squatter

Landlord battling pancreatic cancer fighting to evict squatter

2:10
NYS Federation of Taxi Drivers offer $5,000 reward after string of carjackings and robberies

NYS Federation of Taxi Drivers offer $5,000 reward after string of carjackings and robberies

2:09
Federal civil rights complaint filed against NYC Public Schools Athletic League

Federal civil rights complaint filed against NYC Public Schools Athletic League

1:37
Affordable housing projects coming to Boerum Hill

Affordable housing projects coming to Boerum Hill

1:42
NY Road Runners announce new initiative with NYC Public Schools

NY Road Runners announce new initiative with NYC Public Schools

1:59
Police: Around $62,000 worth of jewelry stolen from 2 Williamsburg stores in separate incidents

Police: Around $62,000 worth of jewelry stolen from 2 Williamsburg stores in separate incidents

Police: Driver arrested in crash that killed 10-year-old girl in Williamsburg

Police: Driver arrested in crash that killed 10-year-old girl in Williamsburg