‘There’s two sides to the story’ – The complicated history of Columbus Day

Oct. 14 officially marked Columbus Day across most of the United States – a holiday to celebrate explorer Christopher Columbus.

News 12 Staff

Oct 15, 2019, 2:24 AM

Updated 1,665 days ago

Share:

Oct. 14 officially marked Columbus Day across most of the United States – a holiday to celebrate explorer Christopher Columbus.
But in certain areas around the country – including parts of New Jersey – the holiday has been changed to Indigenous Peoples Day. It is a day to celebrate the native people who were in North America before Columbus. Those who created the holiday say that it is also a way to expose what they say are negative actions Columbus is responsible for.
New Jerseyans walking near the Christopher Columbus statue in Jersey City’s Journal Square seemed to be mixed on the debate about Columbus.
“Well, he helped discover America, he was an explorer. Or course he was also an exploiter. So, I guess there's two sides to the story,” says one New Jersey resident.
The owner of a Moroccan food truck in Jersey City says that it is because of Columbus that he has the opportunities he has today.
“He came to America and because of him we have this country. It's great, we built it and we try hard,” the food truck owner says.
Those opposed to Columbus Day say that Columbus was cruel to the native people in North America, leading to many deaths.
Some say that while he didn’t really discover America, he should be recognized for his explorer skills.
“How are you going to discover something when people were already here? You can still give him credit because he sailed around the world. You gotta respect both,” said on Jersey City man.
In New Jersey, only Newark and Princeton celebrate Indigenous Peoples Day.


More from News 12
1:57
Bushwick building owner cited for illegal work performed before fire destroyed supermarket, apartments

Bushwick building owner cited for illegal work performed before fire destroyed supermarket, apartments

1:44
Cool and cloudy with mild temperatures for NYC; tracking thunderstorms midweek

Cool and cloudy with mild temperatures for NYC; tracking thunderstorms midweek

1:26
Police: Cyclist struck by car overnight in Bushwick in critical condition

Police: Cyclist struck by car overnight in Bushwick in critical condition

1:24
Lawmakers crack down on theft against small retail, businesses owners in Brooklyn

Lawmakers crack down on theft against small retail, businesses owners in Brooklyn

0:24
Police: Man injured from overnight shooting in Brownsville

Police: Man injured from overnight shooting in Brownsville

New York City National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

New York City National Teacher Appreciation Week Photos

1:15
NYPD: 23-year-old woman struck by B41 bus in Downtown Brooklyn

NYPD: 23-year-old woman struck by B41 bus in Downtown Brooklyn

1:35
4th annual People's Ball returns to the Brooklyn Public Library

4th annual People's Ball returns to the Brooklyn Public Library

1:43
Interested in transforming public pool sites in New York City? Here's how to submit your ideas

Interested in transforming public pool sites in New York City? Here's how to submit your ideas

2:09
Riverdale Restaurant Week kicks off for the season

Riverdale Restaurant Week kicks off for the season

0:32
NYPD: Man pistol-whipped taxi driver in Olinville, fired shots at vehicle; suspect sought

NYPD: Man pistol-whipped taxi driver in Olinville, fired shots at vehicle; suspect sought

0:30
Zibanejad has 2 goals and 1 assist, Panarin scores as Rangers beat Hurricanes 4-3 in Game 1

Zibanejad has 2 goals and 1 assist, Panarin scores as Rangers beat Hurricanes 4-3 in Game 1

1:53
Ditmas Park residents fed up with only building elevator being out of service for a year

Ditmas Park residents fed up with only building elevator being out of service for a year

1:48
Mott Haven art exhibit celebrates Indian Arrival Day

Mott Haven art exhibit celebrates Indian Arrival Day

1:48
FDNY: Rooftop fire spreads into apartment in Crown Heights

FDNY: Rooftop fire spreads into apartment in Crown Heights

1:22
Early Red Nose Day festivities kick off in Dumbo

Early Red Nose Day festivities kick off in Dumbo

2:06
Community-run green space needs help to keep produce growing

Community-run green space needs help to keep produce growing

2:13
FDNY: 1 critical, firefighter injured in East Flatbush apartment fire

FDNY: 1 critical, firefighter injured in East Flatbush apartment fire

2:06
New guidance says women need to be screened for breast cancer at 40 or younger

New guidance says women need to be screened for breast cancer at 40 or younger

2:00
Families devastated after learning 2 Brooklyn Catholic schools will be shutting down

Families devastated after learning 2 Brooklyn Catholic schools will be shutting down