News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Taking Action

Bed-Stuy neighbors push back on plan to turn high school lot into affordable housing

Neighbors said the area is already densely populated and what they really need right now are more spaces for the community to enjoy.

Melissa Rose Cooper

Sep 4, 2025, 6:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Neighbors in Bed-Stuy are pushing back on a plan that would turn a lot at the historic Girls High School into affordable housing.

"We would love to see public land be in service of the community," said Omar Walker, head of the 200 Jefferson Avenue Block Association. "Trading this off to a private developer, it's just unethical."

But Walker says that's exactly what the city plans to do under the Atlantic Ave Mixed-Use Plan. The project calls for redeveloping a roughly 20 block stretch of Atlantic Avenue and nearby streets, with hundreds of homes set aside for affordable housing.

"I really would wish people, especially our politicians, would stop using the words affordable housing," said Walker. "It's misleading."

A longtime resident of Bed-Stuy, Walker is joining about 2,000 neighbors who have signed a petition under the Thrive Bed-Stuy initiative organized by the Halsey and Macon Street Block Associations. They're demanding local leaders ensure the site remain a publicly owned space.

"Affordable housing does not serve communities," he said. "We see it already 1215 Fulton St., an affordable housing building that was just constructed within blocks of this site, almost $3,000 for a studio. How does that make sense? That's luxury housing."

Neighbors said the area is already densely populated and what they really need right now are more spaces for the community to enjoy.

"I'm interested in keeping Bed-Stuy whole. My grandmother attended this school," said Ayisha Doyle. "Though we have beautiful tree lined blocks, we do not have large green spaces or swaths of green spaces residents can use."

Sources close to the project told News 12 the city has no plans on selling the site to a private developer and instead. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development has agreed to issue a request for proposals for a 100 percent permanently affordable, mixed-use building. But neighbors argue creating a space for community events, like a local market or park, would be a better support for both residents and businesses.

More Stories

Top Stories

cimassshootingarrest

Arrest made in Coney Island mass shooting that injured 4 children

01:10
F 12 Hr Planner

Scattered showers and storms return with heat and humidity for Brooklyn

01:54
78edricnoon_2026-07-08-12-34-11

Two men arrested in Bed-Stuy collision that sent car into building, injuring three people

02:33
HEATHERBUSES_2026-07-08-17-20-01_17-10-33,22

Fast buses? NYC’s $882 million plan to speed up buses and improve transit access

02:05
78kellypkg_2026-07-08-05-55-35

Beloved Greenpoint doughnut shop owner dies at 69, leaving community in mourning

01:47
RTBKUnionStDOAArrestTHarfmann1030pm_2026-07-07-22-36-13

Sources: Man accused of hiding roommate's decomposed body inside their Crown Heights apartment

hatecrimesheepsheadbaypic

Man wanted for writing anti-Islamic statements on playground, building in Sheepshead Bay

00:27
78clycospora_2026-07-08-07-23-41

Cyclospora on the rise in New York: What to know about parasite causing severe stomach sickness

01:47
Tomato

Trouble with your tomatoes? Try these 5 tips to keep getting tasty fruit all summer long

02:00
RTBKConeyIslandGunViolenceRallyMScott1030pm_2026-07-07-22-46-35

Family of Coney Island shooting victims speaks out as community demands action

00:42
laundromatshootingarrestthumb

Arrest made in fatal Flatlands laundromat shooting

01:56
treesdownJULIA530pZC_2026-07-07-17-55-03

Storms leave downed trees and powerlines across Brooklyn

01:44
stationaccessibilityMRC530pZC_2026-07-07-17-55-56

$15B in congestion pricing funds will help upgrade several subway stations

01:47
legionnairesUES10pZC_2026-07-07-22-26-50

NYC Health Department investigates Upper East Side Legionnaires’ disease cluster

02:27
HEATHERSALARY5PM_2026-07-07-17-25-42

NYC Council weighs first salary hike for top elected officials since 2016

02:13
ERICACOLLAPSE_2026-07-07-17-14-54

Multiple buildings in Manhattan evacuated after steel building beam compromised

POLICE INVOLVED SHOOTING GENERIC

West Orange man charged with attempted murder after NYPD detective shot in Brooklyn

00:22
1356-26 Hate Crime Assault 7 Pct 04-29-26 Photo

Brooklyn man facing hate crime charges after assaulting a child in a Manhattan playground

01:25
BKedric577_2026-07-07-06-05-59_05-31-52,04

Man shot inside Bay View Houses apartment building in Canarsie; gunman still on the run

02:00
BKrebuild77_2026-07-07-06-53-00

East Flatbush church completes major renovations

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices