Closing arguments delivered at actor's Bronx trial

Closing arguments were made Tuesday in the trial of Lillo Brancato Jr., the former actor accused of second-degree murder in the shooting death of an off-duty NYPD officer. In their summations, the prosecution

News 12 Staff

Dec 17, 2008, 4:36 PM

Updated 5,642 days ago

Share:

Closing arguments delivered at actor's Bronx trial
Closing arguments were made Tuesday in the trial of Lillo Brancato Jr., the former actor accused of second-degree murder in the shooting death of an off-duty NYPD officer.
In their summations, the prosecution and defense left the jury with one question to answer: Is Brancato a cop-killing robber or was the ex-actor, who once appeared regularly on "The Sopranos," simply in the wrong place at the wrong time?
Brancato faces the murder charge in the 2005 killing of off-duty police Officer Daniel Enchautegui in Pelham Bay. Brancato's co-defendant, Steven Armento, was convicted of first-degree murder on Oct. 30 and later sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Brancato has said he was suffering from heroin withdrawal when he and Armento went to an apartment where the actor had obtained drugs before. Authorities say Armento and Brancato broke into the basement apartment to steal prescription drugs after a night of drinking at a strip club.
Enchautegui had returned home after finishing a late shift when he heard glass breaking at the residence next door. When he went to investigate, Armento fired at him, striking him in the chest.
Brancato's defense team tried to argue during the trial that its client was not armed and was unaware Armento was carrying a weapon. Prosecutors charged Brancato with second-degree murder because they say the officer was killed during a felony burglary.
"If Lillo didn't try to enter [the apartment], this is not a burglary," said Joseph Tacopina, Brancato's lawyer. "If it's not a burglary, Lillo is not guilty."
Brancato takes stand at murder trial Allegeddrug dealer testifies at Brancato trialWitness:Brancato was addicted to drugs in 2005Clericalmix-up puts Brancato trial on holdDoctortestifies in Lillo Brancato Jr. trial


More from News 12
2:15
Brooklyn DA announces indictment of 18 alleged Blood gang members

Brooklyn DA announces indictment of 18 alleged Blood gang members

1:40
Tracking nighttime showers before a warm and comfortable Thursday in Brooklyn

Tracking nighttime showers before a warm and comfortable Thursday in Brooklyn

1:53
James Madison HS alumni honor Ruth Bader Ginsburg with street renaming

James Madison HS alumni honor Ruth Bader Ginsburg with street renaming

0:52
Video shows man drive on sidewalk, allegedly yell antisemitic slurs

Video shows man drive on sidewalk, allegedly yell antisemitic slurs

1:43
Cricket makes waves in Brooklyn ahead of World Cup

Cricket makes waves in Brooklyn ahead of World Cup

1:47
Meeting held to inform Brooklyn residents about casino licenses ahead of 'The Coney' proposal

Meeting held to inform Brooklyn residents about casino licenses ahead of 'The Coney' proposal

1:20
Firefighters find e-bike in aftermath of Albany Houses fire in Brooklyn

Firefighters find e-bike in aftermath of Albany Houses fire in Brooklyn

1:38
New renderings of proposed Coney Island casino released

New renderings of proposed Coney Island casino released

NYPD: 20-year-old man found dead in water under Verrazano Bridge

NYPD: 20-year-old man found dead in water under Verrazano Bridge

1:17
NYC invests $10M to new small business loan fund, North Brooklyn cited as adding most businesses since 2019

NYC invests $10M to new small business loan fund, North Brooklyn cited as adding most businesses since 2019

0:31
MTA to hold public webinars on congestion pricing in NYC

MTA to hold public webinars on congestion pricing in NYC

1:32
Father’s Day Gift Ideas: Exclusive Deals – Up to 50% OFF!

Father’s Day Gift Ideas: Exclusive Deals – Up to 50% OFF!

0:29
Brooklyn man sentenced to 25 years to life for 2018 deadly shooting

Brooklyn man sentenced to 25 years to life for 2018 deadly shooting

1:26
NYPD finds millions of dollars of illegal cannabis products in Fort Greene amid ongoing citywide crackdown

NYPD finds millions of dollars of illegal cannabis products in Fort Greene amid ongoing citywide crackdown

1:32
Canarsie residents says vibrations causing damage to homes

Canarsie residents says vibrations causing damage to homes

1:45
Melaquain Anderson's family walks during commencement to receive posthumous degree

Melaquain Anderson's family walks during commencement to receive posthumous degree

1:49
Neighbors: Car drove into pole in Bay Ridge

Neighbors: Car drove into pole in Bay Ridge

1:01
Death of at least 1 person found in Midwood home now being investigated as a homicide

Death of at least 1 person found in Midwood home now being investigated as a homicide

0:20
Brooklyn man faces several hate crime charges for four incidents

Brooklyn man faces several hate crime charges for four incidents

1:22
DOT: Exit 1 ramp on Prospect Expressway to be closed overnight this week for repair work

DOT: Exit 1 ramp on Prospect Expressway to be closed overnight this week for repair work