News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Rebuilding Brooklyn

Investigations Continue After Two Men Found Dead in Brooklyn Creek

The recent deaths have prompted concerns about nightlife safety in East Williamsburg from community members, who hope the city will take action to improve security in the area

News 12 Staff

Aug 2, 2023, 11:11 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Investigations continue as NYPD officers are still piecing together what happened after two men were found dead in the waters of Newtown Creek less than two months apart.

People in the Williamsburg community are calling on the city to ensure nightlife safety in East Williamsburg, saying they’re worried about the future of nightlife in the area. They hope the city has a plan to improve safety.

“I think it’s shaken up more than just Williamsburg, to be honest. I think folks in Ridgewood and nearby Bushwick also, but citywide,” said Councilmember Jennifer Gutiérrez, who says her inbox has been flooded with concerns from constituents after the two bodies were found.

“I think people have a right to be scared. We haven’t gotten a full rundown from the NYPD on the sequence of events and what happened in both instances," Gutiérrez said.

On Tuesday, officers recovered the body of John Castic after investigators said he was last seen at the Brooklyn Mirage over the weekend. Castic is the second man to disappear after leaving the venue. Nearly two months ago, Karl Clemente was reported missing and days later, his body was found floating in the same creek.

People in the community say it gets very dark at night after leaving the Brooklyn Mirage, with little to no cell service. The Brooklyn Mirage said in an Instagram post that they are saddened by the recent deaths of Castic and Clemente. Out of respect for those affected, they declined further comment.

Police say they are still investigating if the two incidents are connected.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:51
DenisReynoso_04062026_subclip_2026-06-04-18-10-15

Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso vows to ‘close the gap’ for working-class New Yorkers in Congress

01:49
NY F P2 PM 1

Ferocious heat arrives for Friday in Brooklyn

01:19
AuroraWoodhull_04062026_subclip_2026-06-04-17-51-58

Street redesign causes Carroll Gardens neighborhood debate

01:43
BurnsWorldCup_04062026_subclip_2026-06-04-17-18-05

'It's going to probably be insane.’ MTA prepares for travel ahead of the FIFA World Cup

01:10
64EDRICNOON_2026-06-04-12-37-35

Man stabbed in the face in Williamsburg

02:06
nychatenantsrallyCM_2026-06-03-22-49-17

Residents seek repairs, answers and reassurance about the future of public housing

00:32
530AKnifepointRobbST_2026-06-04-06-06-05

Man robbed at knifepoint near Sunset Park urgent care; two men on the run

01:37
Screenshot 2026-06-04 150138

Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty earn 2026 Tony nominations for 'Two Strangers'

00:27
Wilton Mugs

Two men have been charged in a $300,000 town of Wilton check theft following a multi-state investigation

01:30
83yoslashedCM_2026-06-03-17-34-01

83-year-old Brownsville woman attacked while on her way to church, homeless man charged

01:49
oshaesibleydeliberations10pmCM_2026-06-03-22-18-59

Jury deliberations continue in murder trial of man accused of killing O'Shae Sibley

02:22
Screenshot 2026-06-03 184332

New York Knicks postseason generates $202 million in local economy

01:37
64rebuildingbrooklyn_2026-06-04-06-42-39

East Williamsburg lands $20M state grant for housing, parks and business growth

02:04
642026NJrizzo_2026-06-04-05-42-00

Down The Shore: Penguins steal the spotlight at Jenkinson's Aquarium

02:16
roadtripbartowpellmansionCM_2026-06-03-22-28-57

Bronx mansion offers a glimpse into America's history ahead of 250th anniversary

01:55
crimestatsmayCM_2026-06-03-22-46-00

NYPD: Murder down citywide, despite violent week in Brooklyn

00:35
hatecrimeindictment5pZC_2026-06-03-18-03-51

Bronx man indicted for hate crime, accused of attacking man at knifepoint at Williamsburg subway station

01:57
bushwickinletparkopeningCM_2026-06-03-17-51-58

After years of delays, new section of Bushwick Inlet Park opens on Brooklyn waterfront

02:42
5PMBXKLNHOUSINGHEATHER_2026-06-03-17-12-45

Taking a look inside the NYC units sitting empty for years as renovation costs soar

00:33
IMG 3126

Landlord accused of partially demolishing building with 8 children inside after lying on permit request

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices