Rebuilding Brooklyn
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
Taking Action
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
FIFA World Cup

Investigations Continue After Two Men Found Dead in Brooklyn Creek

The recent deaths have prompted concerns about nightlife safety in East Williamsburg from community members, who hope the city will take action to improve security in the area

News 12 Staff

Aug 2, 2023, 11:11 PM

Updated

Share:

Investigations continue as NYPD officers are still piecing together what happened after two men were found dead in the waters of Newtown Creek less than two months apart.

People in the Williamsburg community are calling on the city to ensure nightlife safety in East Williamsburg, saying they’re worried about the future of nightlife in the area. They hope the city has a plan to improve safety.

“I think it’s shaken up more than just Williamsburg, to be honest. I think folks in Ridgewood and nearby Bushwick also, but citywide,” said Councilmember Jennifer Gutiérrez, who says her inbox has been flooded with concerns from constituents after the two bodies were found.

“I think people have a right to be scared. We haven’t gotten a full rundown from the NYPD on the sequence of events and what happened in both instances," Gutiérrez said.

On Tuesday, officers recovered the body of John Castic after investigators said he was last seen at the Brooklyn Mirage over the weekend. Castic is the second man to disappear after leaving the venue. Nearly two months ago, Karl Clemente was reported missing and days later, his body was found floating in the same creek.

People in the community say it gets very dark at night after leaving the Brooklyn Mirage, with little to no cell service. The Brooklyn Mirage said in an Instagram post that they are saddened by the recent deaths of Castic and Clemente. Out of respect for those affected, they declined further comment.

Police say they are still investigating if the two incidents are connected.

Top Stories

00:22
FairfieldMVA_2026-04-22-11-34-39

Car crashes into utility pole at Fairfield intersection, driver hospitalized

01:47
ct 4

Showers today with warmer air on the doorstep

00:18
FlaDrowning_2026-04-22-07-06-00

Connecticut man identified as victim of fatal Florida drowning

00:43
NewAIRegs_2026-04-22-11-39-32

New AI safeguards move forward as Connecticut Senate approves child protection bill

Electric Rates

Electric rates set to drop May 1 as PURA announces relief for Connecticut customers

00:26
stamfordsentencing0421_2026-04-21-21-03-19

Stamford parents sentenced in connection to death of 2-year-old son

03:31
CC422_2026-04-22-07-25-24

Conversation Connecticut: 5th Annual Norwalk Earth Day Festival happening this Saturday

01:32
Mark7aml422_2026-04-22-07-19-53

Veganish Cafe in Bridgeport stresses the importance of eating healthy on Earth Day and every day

00:24
Screenshot 2026-04-22 061825

High school senior honors fallen firefighters through Eagle Scout project

02:36
Screenshot 2026-04-22 052558

The Voice of the Subway: Meet Bernie Wagenblast, the person behind the MTA’s most familiar announcement

02:20
RTCTBptMentalHealthFRecchia9pm_2026-04-21-21-24-10

Officials: Several recent suicides in Bridgeport spark stepped-up prevention effort

01:57
justinpkg0421_2026-04-21-21-17-00

'We want the respect we deserve.' Quinnipiac women's rugby team continues fighting to reinstate program

02:28
johnpkg0421_2026-04-21-16-51-24

'Vax confusion.' CT lawmakers look to guarantee vaccine access despite federal changes

00:30
k9scup0421_2026-04-21-21-29-25

K-9 finds fish that were too small to be caught and retained from the Housatonic River

00:45
handandhand0421_2026-04-21-21-23-03

Wakeman Boys & Girls Club honors members during an annual awards celebration

02:40
marissapkg0421_2026-04-21-16-50-22

Stamford condo residents wonder when they can return, what the future holds after units condemned

00:30
k9scup0421_2026-04-21-21-29-25

K-9 finds fish that were too small to be caught and retained from the Housatonic River

00:24
Plymouth County Sheriffs Dept

Cheshire teenager released from ICE detention center after more than two weeks

00:47
Wilton Police New Headquarters

Wilton PD opens new headquarters on Danbury Road

00:36
murphy(chris) copy1

Sen. Chris Murphy faces controversy over social media response to Iranian ships evading U.S. blockade

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices