News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Power & Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Hot Toys
Fair or Mostly Clear
51°
Local
Crime
Weather
Power & Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Hot Toys

Investigations Continue After Two Men Found Dead in Brooklyn Creek

The recent deaths have prompted concerns about nightlife safety in East Williamsburg from community members, who hope the city will take action to improve security in the area

News 12 Staff

•

Aug 2, 2023, 11:11 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Investigations continue as NYPD officers are still piecing together what happened after two men were found dead in the waters of Newtown Creek less than two months apart.

People in the Williamsburg community are calling on the city to ensure nightlife safety in East Williamsburg, saying they’re worried about the future of nightlife in the area. They hope the city has a plan to improve safety.

“I think it’s shaken up more than just Williamsburg, to be honest. I think folks in Ridgewood and nearby Bushwick also, but citywide,” said Councilmember Jennifer Gutiérrez, who says her inbox has been flooded with concerns from constituents after the two bodies were found.

“I think people have a right to be scared. We haven’t gotten a full rundown from the NYPD on the sequence of events and what happened in both instances," Gutiérrez said.

On Tuesday, officers recovered the body of John Castic after investigators said he was last seen at the Brooklyn Mirage over the weekend. Castic is the second man to disappear after leaving the venue. Nearly two months ago, Karl Clemente was reported missing and days later, his body was found floating in the same creek.

People in the community say it gets very dark at night after leaving the Brooklyn Mirage, with little to no cell service. The Brooklyn Mirage said in an Instagram post that they are saddened by the recent deaths of Castic and Clemente. Out of respect for those affected, they declined further comment.

Police say they are still investigating if the two incidents are connected.

Top Stories

01:28
RTREGBKCanarsieShelterRallyTHarfmann9pm

Dozens rally in Canarsie against plan to build 200-bed single men's shelter near middle school

01:18
LN F P2 PM 1

Mix of sun and clouds for Tuesday in Brooklyn; tracking storm to finish to the week

01:54
SBBKJoggerStabCaseLatestJBurns4pm

'It's scary.' School aide charged in fatal stabbing of female jogger

00:27
RTREGBK52ndStShotFolo11092026VO9pm

Man arraigned in East Flatbush shooting that left 60-year-old woman injured

01:35
Screenshot 2026-11-09 215617

Brooklyn neighbors react to BQE repair plan ahead of public meeting

00:20
RTREGBXBKVeteransDayParadeVO9pm

Preparations underway for NYC Veterans Day parade

01:47
110926BK Scott Floating Classrooms

NYC Ferry, Billion Oyster Project launch floating classrooms for 10,000 students

01:35
RTREGBXBKCitywideWinterResponseNHernandez4pm

NYC Mayor's Office announces $25 million winter response expansion, upgrades to snow removal

01:43
blumenthalnotbackingschumerCM_2026-11-09-16-55-39

Will Chuck Schumer return as U.S. Senate leader? CT Sen. Richard Blumenthal declines to back him

01:29
RGCRIMESTATSCALIX11926_2026-11-09-06-34-58

NYPD announces fewest shooting and murders in first 10 months of 2026

00:17
RTREGBKRidgewoodAveFire11092026VO4pm

1 person injured in Cypress Hills basement fire

01:07
RGCALIXTOHW11926_2026-11-09-05-41-04

Fort Hamilton Parkway Bridge over Gowanus Expressway to temporarily close for repairs

AP26301250105879

Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky launches bid to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth

02:01
8f55dabc-7ee7-46e6-8eef-ea14631de5b5

Made in Brooklyn: L'Appartement 4F bakery serves up traditional French croissants

01:07
a740854b-9b56-4ee5-8959-345563967baa

Hot Toys: Squishies, and how to spot the fakes!

01:38
thnksgiving1

The Cost Of: Thanksgiving Side Dishes

01:17
RTREGCTBKStratfordI95CrashESalinas6pmSG001

2 Brooklyn residents ID'ed in deadly Connecticut crash off I-95 exit ramp

00:50
RTREGBKCeremonyForLtPBradyVOSOTVO9pm_2026-11-08-21-38-11

FDNY honors firefighter who died a year ago while battling Brooklyn fire

Screenshot 2026-11-08 115339

DOE school aide arraigned, held without bail in killing of Brooklyn jogger Katie Suarez

01:41
VOICEINTRANSPORTATIONPROJECTSKLN6PZC_2026-11-08-18-20-57

New ballot measure sparks concerns about public input on NYC street changes

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices