As mail theft continues to plague communities across the country, the U.S. Postal Service has launched a nationwide effort to modernize mailbox security. But some experts warn the pace of those upgrades may not be enough to stop criminals who are exploiting a decades-old system.
For Mike LoMonico, the threat feels personal.
LoMonico became a victim of check fraud after a stolen check was altered and fraudulently cashed for nearly $5,000. The experience has changed the way he sends mail.
"It's very scary that we're that unsafe," LoMonico said.
"We pretty much stopped sending checks out and we don't use mailboxes at all. We go physically to the post office and hand it to them there."
Authorities say some mail thefts are being carried out using stolen Postal Service Arrow keys, which give carriers access to outdoor collection boxes and other mail receptacles. A single Arrow key can open every mailbox within a designated ZIP code area, making the keys highly valuable to criminals.
In response, the Postal Service launched Operation Safe Delivery in 2023, a nationwide initiative aimed at improving mail security and reducing theft.
As part of the program, nearly 50,000 mailboxes have been equipped with new electronic locking systems. The Postal Service also plans to install another 50,000 high-security electronic locks that use programmable keys capable of being disabled if they are lost or stolen.
Supporters say the technology represents a significant improvement over traditional mechanical locks, which can remain vulnerable if keys are stolen or duplicated.
However, critics argue the upgrades still cover only a tiny fraction of the nation's mail infrastructure.
"Unfortunately there are over 9 million Arrow key locks and that accounts for less than one percent," said Frank Albergo, executive director of the Postal Police Officers Association. "So that's not going to do much."
Questions have also been raised about how well the Postal Service safeguards existing Arrow keys.
A recent audit by the Postal Service Office of Inspector General found that security procedures designed to track and protect the keys were not always being followed. According to the audit, Arrow keys were discovered in or near unsecured storage cabinets, unlocked supervisors' desks, registry cages and carrier workstations. In some cases, carriers were found with the keys while off duty.
The audit also found that missing keys were not consistently reported, potentially delaying efforts to deactivate locks or investigate thefts.
In response to the findings, Postal Service management said it has already begun implementing corrective measures and is developing additional plans to strengthen Arrow key controls and accountability.