News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Taking Action

NYC subway service is disrupted for a second day after low-speed collision that injured more than 20

New York City subway service was disrupted for a second day Friday as transit workers labored in the cramped confines of a tunnel beneath Manhattan to remove two trains that collided and derailed, causing minor injuries to about two dozen passengers.

Associated Press

Jan 5, 2024, 5:36 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

New York City subway service was disrupted for a second day Friday as transit workers labored in the cramped confines of a tunnel beneath Manhattan to remove two trains that collided and derailed, causing minor injuries to about two dozen passengers.

The crash happened at about 3 p.m. Thursday when a northbound 1 train carrying about 300 passengers was switching from the express track to the local track at the 96th Street station, Metropolitan Transportation Authority officials said. The 1 train collided with an out-of-service train with four workers on board.

“We're grateful that this low-speed collision did not injure more people,” MTA Chair Janno Lieber said at a briefing in front of the station on Friday.

Lieber said partial service would be restored once workers are able to rerail the derailed passenger train and move it out of the way. Nine of the train's 10 cars had been rerailed by Friday morning, he said.

NYC Transit President Richard Davey said getting the 10th car back on track was a complicated operation because of the subway tunnel's low ceiling.

“The final car of the passenger train that derailed, there’s no room, right?” Davey said. “This is a tunnel.”

Transit workers are “literally lifting it a few inches, shimmying it over, lifting it a few, shimmying it over,” Davey said. “So that process takes a while."


Davey said the passenger train had the green light to proceed Thursday but the disabled train did not. “As a result it bumped into the train,” he said. “Why we don’t know, that’s still under investigation.”

A team from the National Transportation Safety Board arrived in New York on Friday to try to investigate the cause of the collision between the passenger train and the other train, which was out of service due to vandalism.

No time has been set for an NTSB briefing on the collision, an agency spokesperson said.

Officials said the vandalized train, whose wheels were damaged by the impact of the collision, will be removed after the passenger train is rerailed.

Derailments and crashes in the 119-year-old New York City subway system are rare. The worst crash in city subway history happened on Nov. 1, 1918, when a speeding train derailed in a sharply curved tunnel in Brooklyn, killing at least 93 people.

More recently, five people died on Aug. 28, 1991, when a 4 train derailed at Manhattan ‘s 14th Street Union Square Station. That train’s motorman was found at fault for alcohol intoxication and served 10 years in prison for manslaughter.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:50
surfavetransformerfireCM_2026-07-15-17-40-51

Transformer fire brings down utility poles, damages cars in Coney Island

01:39
F Smoke All HRRR

Wildfire smoke impacts Brooklynites through the rest of this week

02:32
busactionplanCM_2026-07-15-17-21-25

Tremont Avenue bus redesign launches as city ramps up outreach on Brooklyn bus plans

01:28
heatcontinuesbkCM_2026-07-15-17-41-45

Dangerous heat, possible wildfire smoke create two concerns for New Yorkers

02:20
Lawler

'I let my dad down.' Rep. Mike Lawler opens up about past DWAI arrest in exclusive interview

hit and run arrest

Bronx box truck driver arrested in fatal Brooklyn Heights hit-and-run

01:06
ROCNATIONSS_2026-07-15-12-45-43

Young Guru to sponsor full-tuition scholarship at Roc Nation school

02:05
vintagerugtheft530pZC_2026-07-15-17-42-54

Caught on Camera: $4,000 worth of vintage rugs stolen from Bushwick shop after flood

02:07
715parkfireBK_2026-07-15-05-50-44

Asser Levy Park playground fully restored nearly 2 years after fire

00:30
5a Rikers Officer SentencedST_2026-07-15-05-14-47

Former Rikers officer sentenced for false injury claims on the job

02:03
RTBK86thStSubwayRobMScott10pm_2026-07-14-22-31-06

Commuters say 'not again' after yet another incident at the 86th Street subway station in Gravesend

00:49
CREDIT: AP Photo/Jenny Kane

New York won’t build big data centers for a year as it weighs energy and climate risks

00:24
7152026NJtime_2026-07-15-05-39-26

House passes bill to 'ditch the switch' and make daylight saving time permanent

00:20
Screenshot 2026-07-15 055038

Taco Bell investigated over possible link to parasitic illness outbreak

01:43
715gardenguidenotsure_2026-07-15-05-50-38

Here's why your basil isn't growing and is getting small leaves (and how to fix it!)

01:09
715bxbkccostof_2026-07-15-06-30-48

The Cost Of: Cars

01:23
RTBKMyrtleAveFireTHarfmann5pm_2026-07-14-17-13-24

Citizen app videos show heavy smoke, flames billowing from Clinton Hill apartment

01:58
bballcourthomicide5pZC_2026-07-14-17-40-12

Still no leads: East Flatbush remembers basketball star as police search for his killer

01:54
churchfireinv5pZC_2026-07-14-17-38-31

FDNY investigates Bushwick fire as possibly being set intentionally

01:15
BXBKEducationAnnouncement714noon_2026-07-14-12-26-19

NYC expands preschool special education programs with $67.5 million investment

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices