Rebuilding Brooklyn
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Numbers & Links

Promise kept: Goshen business owner pays back donors who helped him stay afloat following fire

When Sal Mastropolo III, of Authentic Antique Lumber, called the customers and vendors who donated money after a fire put him in a $100,000 hole to return their money, they weren't sure what to think.

Ben Nandy

May 26, 2026, 5:44 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

An Orange County business owner who almost lost everything due to a fire has been calling up all the people who donated to help the business survive to give them their money back.

When Sal Mastropolo III, of Authentic Antique Lumber, called the customers and vendors who donated money after a fire put him in a $100,000 hole to return their money, they weren't sure what to think.

"We're going to send that money back to you and we're going to send you a gift card," Mastropolo told a restaurant manager who donated. "What?" the restaurant manager replied. "But we're not expecting that money back."

"Well, that's what we're doing though," Mastropolo said. "It's the right thing to do."The team there recently remade an entire set of custom-made furniture for that restaurant because the first set was ruined in the September 2024 fire.Mastropolo said a stain rag spontaneously combusted in a trashcan inside the business's sanding and epoxy building.The new building was not yet insured.Several large projects were lost, and the business was on the brink.Mastropolo said that following the fire, he had some vulnerable moments in which he thought he might not be able to save the business.

Mastropolo maxed out his accounts, took out a loan and asked the public for donations.He planned to rebuild the sanding and epoxy building, keep his 18 employees and eventually pay back the 80-plus donors who reached out after News 12's initial story on the fire.The employees had faith.

Lead finisher Terrence Tobak said that after the fire he was thinking more about the business's future than his own.His main focus was starting over on the giant restaurant order.

"It was not so much about 'Where am I going?,' because I know my role here," Tobak said. "It was more so, 'How are we going to pivot and reuse the space that we already have?'"Mastropolo's late father, Sal Mastropolo Jr., started the business in 1972 taking down barns and selling the wood.

News 12 asked Mastropolo what he thinks Sal Jr. would think of the business's recovery.

"He'd probably find something I could have done a little better," he said smiling, "but I think he'd be proud."

More Stories

Top Stories

00:38
Screenshot 2026-05-28 081536

One man stabbed, another slashed in Sunset Park

01:30
LN TODAY

Less humid and a noticeable change in the weather in Brooklyn for the weekend

01:21
BKEdric528_2026-05-28-05-51-11

Man stabbed to death outside Canarsie  shopping center; police searching for 3 women

01:44
BKAurora528_2026-05-28-07-34-52

Boerum Hill hoops hub helps young players build confidence on and off the court

02:25
e678d502-6185-45ab-bcbc-f56418ea6701

Blaze consumes Chinese restaurant in Midwood; 3 firefighters hurt

00:42
womanarrested2024nyehitandrunCM_2026-05-27-22-46-05

Brooklyn woman accused of fatally striking man with her car, dragging him for half a mile in Flatbush hit-and-run

01:22
5282026CTeastend_2026-05-28-06-02-36

The East End: Farmhouse Bed & Breakfast

01:58
mcguinessblvdredesign1030pmCM_2026-05-27-22-49-31

Construction to officially begin for McGuiness Boulevard redesign in Greenpoint

01:39
roadtripbklnmuseumCM_2026-05-27-22-56-53

New 'Sculpting the Senses' exhibition makes North American debut at Brooklyn Museum

01:41
fultonstfatalstabbingCM_2026-05-27-17-33-38

Man stabbed to death near Van Siclen Avenue subway station

happy the elephant

Happy, who taught researchers that elephants can recognize themselves, is euthanized at Bronx Zoo

01:59
subwaysurfingwarningCM_2026-05-27-17-39-36

Mother of teen killed subway surfing joins NYPD to stop deadly trend

01:56
parkslopefoodcoopcontroversyCM_2026-05-27-17-53-07

Park Slope Food Co-op hires security after controversial boycott vote

02:19
summerinnyc5pZC_2026-05-27-17-18-39

NYC launches summer hub to deter teen violence

01:48
527lindsaycommunityhealth_2026-05-27-11-35-53

Exclusive: Apprenticeship program trains next generation of community health workers

00:41
ROBBERY ARREST copy

15-year-old charged with robbery, assault in Flatbush

Screenshot 2026-05-27 044428

Man wanted for strangling, assaulting teen on R train

01:38
RTBKFlatlandsLaundromatShotJBurns530pm_2026-05-26-17-40-14

'His eyes were already gray.' Wife tries to save husband after deadly Flatlands laundromat shooting

01:43
527costof_2026-05-27-06-27-18

The Cost Of: Diapers

02:06
bkchiefshooting5265p_2026-05-26-17-38-14

High-ranking NYPD member placed on modified duty after off-duty parking lot shooting incident in Rockland County

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices