News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
NYC Politics
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Celebrating America's 250th

Families of 9/11 victims outrage over possible plea deal that would avoid death penalty for suspected terrorists

Some say it is not fair for the suspected terrorists to live when so many loved ones have died.

News 12 Staff

Aug 18, 2023, 10:38 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Some families of Sept. 11 victims are outraged after hearing the government is considering a plea deal that would take the death penalty off the table.

Some say it depends on what that plea agreement would include, but others firmly say no, it is not fair for the suspected terrorists to live when so many loved ones have died.

Every Sept. 11, Lorraine Seicol visits The Rising, Westchester County's 9/11 memorial in Valhalla.

"I bring my flowers and make sure I touch every stone, every name," she says.

Seicol knows people who died or escaped the Twin Towers. Now, she and her husband, David, are worried for them again on hearing the government is considering a plea deal that could mean none of the suspected terrorists would face the death penalty.

"There should be no plea deal," David Seicol says. He says he has never favored the death penalty, but in this case he is not so sure and it should be up to the families.

"They're the ones that feel it the most," he says.

The government is asking their opinions.

It has been more than a decade the case against accused mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four others at Guantanamo Bay has been unresolved. Many of the delays are attributed to legal issues around the torture the suspects received. Also, there is the question about whether the case should move from military tribunals to civilian court.

"I think people need to know more details so that we don't forget, that we always remember," David Seicol says.

The Obama administration considered a move, but some victims' families were against it and there was​ concern about security costs. Some feel a plea may not allow them to get more information about possible involvement from Saudi Arabia for example, which has always denied it.

For their friends, the Seicols are among those who feel there should not be a plea deal in the case but feel it has to go through the legal process.

"It's fair to those families because a plea deal is not going to settle their souls," Lorraine Seicol says.

She says the first responders who are now dying from helping at ground zero also need to be heard.

The letter some family members have received from the government asks they respond with their thoughts by Monday.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:10
KLNMETALPIPE_2026-06-27-08-20-44

73-year-old man struck in head with metal pipe in Bensonhurst

01:34
thumbnail

A cloudy Saturday in Brooklyn and a low risk for rain

02:02
akealchristopherhomicidelatestCM_2026-06-26-22-34-42

Brooklyn mother continues plea for justice as 14-year-old son's cold case reaches 14 years

01:49
soccerstreetswatchparty10pmCM_2026-06-26-22-44-26

World Cup watch party brings Brownsville together

01:37
venezuelareliefeffortsCM_2026-06-26-17-35-35

Relief efforts underway in Williamsburg after Venezuela hit with back-to-back earthquakes

01:48
unsanitaryplayground530pZC_2026-06-26-17-51-22

Marine Park splash pad turns into ‘makeshift pool’ due to clogged drain, as residents demand city action

00:33
AP26162046134185

Brooklyn native Jose Alvarado will return to the Knicks on a multiyear deal, AP source says

00:44
626BXfire_2026-06-26-12-33-15

Fire rips through East New York building for second time in less than a year

01:52
626aurorabenefits_2026-06-26-05-58-50

Advocates warn budget cuts could jeopardize vital benefits services

01:36
626shaktilastdayofschoolbrooklyn_2026-06-26-08-31-07

Brooklyn students celebrate last day of public school before longer than usual summer break

01:46
LANDLORDCOSTS1030PAB_2026-06-25-22-57-28

NYC rent freeze sparks outcry from building owners over rising repair costs

00:24
AP26167097406696

Last-place Mets fire manager Carlos Mendoza, replacing him with Andy Green

02:22
rgbfinalvote10pmCM_2026-06-25-22-05-21

Could the historic rent freeze mean poorer living conditions for New Yorkers?

01:57
SUPREMECOURT1030PMAB_2026-06-25-22-50-16

Supreme Court ruling on TPS leaves Brooklyn’s Haitian community on edge

01:52
franklinave2alarmfireCM_2026-06-25-22-41-07

New restaurant destroyed, apartment tenants displaced after 2-alarm fire in Bed Stuy

02:11
FolkNation530PAB_2026-06-25-17-51-49

22 alleged gang members charged in connection with 26 shootings

02:43
rgbfinalvoteCM_2026-06-25-17-10-09

Mamdani responds after Rent Guidelines Board member resigns hours before key vote on NYC rents

01:43
BKedric625_2026-06-25-07-22-43

Dispute over declined card ends with two nail salon employees slashed in Crown Heights

school generic (desks)

Last chance to apply for 2-K seats: Here's what you need to know

00:46
BKSCOTUS62526_2026-06-25-12-49-49

Supreme Court allows Trump administration to end legal protections for Haitians, Syrians

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices