News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Power & Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Hot Toys
Clear
57°
Local
Crime
Weather
Power & Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Rebuilding Brooklyn
Hot Toys

When curbing your trash interferes with your religion

Some Crown Heights residents say trash pickups are interfering with religious obligations.

Julia Joseph

•

Sep 23, 2024, 6:27 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

If you are a resident of New York City, you are probably familiar with the chore of dropping your trash bags on the curb.

Every resident has an allotted day and time to do so.

Most of the time, it is mindless. But what would happen if trash drop off were to interfere with your religious obligations?

Many residents in Crown Heights say that is exactly what they are dealing with.

Since last spring when the Department of Sanitation added stricter drop-off guidelines for trash, parts of Crown Heights now have to drop off trash at the curb between 8 p.m. and midnight, or between 6 p.m. and midnight if it is in a container. Half of the year, when the sun sets before 6 p.m., this policy interferes with Jewish people who observe Shabbat.

Mordechai is one of the men who is affected. He says the new times have become an issue for his community.

With the city's mission to mitigate the rat crisis, the Department of Sanitation told News 12 that New Yorkers, curbing their trash later at night, can help limit the amount of hours that black trash bags sit on the street during the day.

Community members say they think there is a better happy medium to be found.

"Garbage is garbage but on the other hand, you should respect the Jewish religion of the communities that they are picking up in," Mark Parton shares.

News 12 spoke to some community members who say they have incurred countless fines for putting the trash out too early - something many people do in order to avoid taking it out while observing Shabbat.

Joshua Goodman, a representative from sanitation, says they offered a change for collection day, though community leaders declined the offer.

News 12 asked for more specifics about what the proposed change would have entailed, but was left with no response.

News 12 also asked if the Department of Sanitation understands how the current schedule is impacting observant Jews in Brooklyn, and what other solutions might be out there to fix this dilemma, but did not hear back

Top Stories

01:32
Liquor Store Beating Civil Lawsuit

Brooklyn man files federal civil rights lawsuit over liquor store arrest caught on video

00:57
CT F P1 AM

STORM WATCH: Enjoy Wednesday’s sunshine before nor’easter brings heavy rain to Brooklyn

00:16
Man Dies At Rikers

Man dies in custody at Rikers Island

Missing Voices

Homeless Youth in Crisis: The Missing Voices

01:00
RTREGMissingPersonsDay11102026VOSOTVO9pm

Missing Persons Day event provides resources for those searching for loved ones in Brooklyn

01:10
Screenshot 2026-11-10 210003

Williamsburg bookstore turns new page thanks to online fundraiser

01:50
morgan safety

Officials renew calls for safety upgrades along Shore Parkway Promenade after Katie Suarez killing

Article 243275 Thumbnail

From free meals to free haircuts! Here are some popular Veterans Day deals and discounts

01:39
RTREGBKBXNYPDSubwaySurfingAwarenessJBurns4pm_2026-11-10-17-07-49

NYPD, mother of subway surfing victim spread awareness about dangers 1 week after recent incident

00:25
brownsville shooting

Report: Officers who shot and killed man in Brownsville apartment will not be charged

JOGGERSTABBEDARRESTKLN6PZC_2026-11-07-19-05-58

Grand jury indicts man charged in killing of Brooklyn jogger Katie Suarez

00:23
image

NYPD identifies 3 of 6 victims killed in devastating Sunset Park fire

00:15
car fire verrazzano

Vehicle catches on fire on Verrazzano Bridge

01:34
kingsplaza1

Rebuilding Brooklyn: Exploring Kings Plaza's new upgrades

01:28
RTREGBKCanarsieShelterRallyTHarfmann9pm

Dozens rally in Canarsie against plan to build 200-bed single men's shelter near middle school

01:02
ce72a972-e171-4ec8-8a63-a6c1ae81b689

Hot Toys: Character craze toy guide from KPop Demon Hunters to Paw Patrol and more

01:54
SBBKJoggerStabCaseLatestJBurns4pm

'It's scary.' School aide charged in fatal stabbing of female jogger

00:27
RTREGBK52ndStShotFolo11092026VO9pm

Man arraigned in East Flatbush shooting that left 60-year-old woman injured

01:35
Screenshot 2026-11-09 215617

Brooklyn neighbors react to BQE repair plan ahead of public meeting

00:20
RTREGBXBKVeteransDayParadeVO9pm

Preparations underway for NYC Veterans Day parade

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices