A proposed New York City law aimed at improving safety for delivery workers is drawing pushback from independent delivery business owners, who warn it could threaten their livelihoods and thousands of jobs.
The Delivery Protection Act would require large delivery companies to license their facilities, follow workplace and street safety requirements, and directly employ certain delivery workers instead of relying on outside contractors.
Council Member Tiffany Cabán, who introduced the legislation, says the changes are necessary to protect workers.
But independent delivery business owners who contract with companies like Amazon argue the proposed restrictions could prevent them from continuing to operate.
Amazon has also entered the debate, sending alerts to New York City customers warning that the legislation could increase delivery costs by up to $5 per delivery.
“This is corporate bullying at its best,” Cabán said. "There's no world that a commonsense bill like this would cost Amazon $5 for every single delivery.”
Cabán says the licensing fee would be $500 every two years and points to workplace injury data as evidence of the need for stronger protections.
However, business owners say the legislation could have unintended consequences.
Juan Martinez operates an independent delivery company out of Red Hook, Brooklyn, that contracts with Amazon. He says he employs approximately 170 workers and delivers around 20,000 packages daily.
“It would literally put me out of business,” Martinez said.
He argues that requiring companies like Amazon to directly employ delivery workers could eliminate the contracting arrangement his business depends on.
Another delivery business owner operating in the Bronx and Brooklyn says small businesses should have more input before the legislation moves forward.
“Give us an opportunity. Sit down with us so that you can hear from us on what it is that we’ve been doing for our communities and for this city,” he said.
Cabán disputes the suggestion that workers and businesses have been excluded from the process.
“We’ve talked to hundreds and hundreds of workers. We’ve had those conversations. And we understand that this is the right thing to do,” she said.
Cabán says the bill has enough support to pass the City Council, while opponents continue calling for additional discussions before a vote.