Beneath layers of graffiti and grime stands the former Hook and Ladder Company No. 6 firehouse, a Greenpoint landmark with roots dating back to the 1850s. Once a vital part of the neighborhood’s civic life, the historic building now sits vacant and at the center of a growing debate.

Preservation advocates say the firehouse’s designation within the Greenpoint Historic District is intentional.

“It was designated for a reason,” said Frampton Tolbert, executive director of the Historic Districts Council. “Even though it’s no longer serving as a firehouse, people still see it as part of the civic history of the neighborhood.”

But that history may soon face change. The property is now being considered for redevelopment, a prospect that has some residents worried construction could compromise the building’s historic integrity.

Neighbor Joseph Carranza says the possibility hits close to home.

“It kind of makes me sad,” he said. “To live across the street from an old fire station is a really cool thing. It was here before me, and I just hope that whatever it becomes, it still reflects the past.”

Not everyone agrees. Other residents view the structure as a long-neglected eyesore. “It’s just an abandoned, derelict building,” said Mikhail Bortnik. “I don’t know what history there is in something that’s been abandoned for over two decades.”

While the site is considered prime for development, preservation officials emphasize that any changes must first be approved by the Landmarks Preservation Commission.

Tolbert says that process often leads to better outcomes.

“Making sure these reflect neighboring buildings and add to the streetscape is key,” he said. “A lot of times, what we get is better design.”

No official plans have currently been announced. Until then, the former firehouse remains standing - a weathered but enduring piece of Greenpoint’s history.