Rebuilding Brooklyn
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
Taking Action
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Police: Brooklyn man fatally stabbed in City Hall subway station

Officials say the 38-year-old was pronounced dead shortly after.

News 12 Staff

•

Apr 26, 2025, 8:32 AM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Police say a Brooklyn man was fatally stabbed inside of the City Hall subway station.

Investigators believe John Sheldon stepped on another man's shoe before he was stabbed.

Officials say the 38-year-old was pronounced dead shortly after.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:31
captainmamdanicomments530pZC_2026-05-05-17-59-49

‘Not my mayor.’ NYPD disciplines Brooklyn police captain after viral video of him bad-mouthing Mamdani, Democrats

01:37
NY FM Temp 4k GRAF

Rounds of rain and retreating temperatures for Wednesday in Brooklyn

02:03
fewermurdercrimestatsbk1030pmCM_2026-05-05-22-42-08

NYPD reports fewest murders in recorded history

02:01
bktenantsrentstrikeCM_2026-05-05-17-34-24

East Flatbush tenants go on rent strike over poor living conditions inside apartments

01:24
bikeparkingprogramlatestCM_2026-05-05-22-50-56

City to start installing bike storage units across the 5 boroughs

00:31
jamaciaavefatalcollision1030pZC_2026-05-05-22-42-30

Electric scooter rider dies in crash blocks from his Cypress Hills home

01:48
bushwickinletparkCM_2026-05-05-17-53-38

New beach opens at Bushwick Inlet Park in Greenpoint

02:30
BX5PMLINDSAYSCHOOL_2026-05-05-17-16-10

Woman arrested after posing as student at Pelham Bay school

02:17
BX5PMHEATHERCOMMISH_2026-05-05-17-17-55

Mayor Mamdani appoints new commissioner for Office of Community Safety

00:40
BX12PCATWATER_2026-05-05-12-09-53

NYPD body camera footage shows woman and her cat rescued under the Brooklyn Bridge

01:33
BKEDRICSLASHING55262_2026-05-05-12-37-06

Man slashed with machete in Sunset Park; attackers still on the run

recalled chips

Certain Utz potato chips recalled due to possible salmonella

00:35
BXTIMESSQUARESTABBING55265A_2026-05-05-05-25-37

Man stabbed to death in Times Square

01:36
BKJUNIUSREV5526_2026-05-05-05-49-55

Junius and Livonia Train station get major ADA-accessibility boost

00:27
BKSUNSETPARK5526_2026-05-05-07-00-09

Sunset Park Greenway officially opens marking new improvements to the neighborhood

00:30
BXEVHYBRID5526_2026-05-05-06-41-08

Switching to electric vehicles due to high gas prices? Consider the weather before doing so.

00:30
BXANTISEM5526_2026-05-05-06-41-23

4 people wanted in connection to spraying antisemitic graffiti in Queens

00:48
buildingdemowilliamsburgCM_2026-05-05-14-10-15

3 firefighters suffer minor injuries after East Williamsburg fire causes partial collapse

01:53
Screenshot 2026-05-04 154853

Brooklyn College will now allow students to walk the stage at graduation

02:01
Screenshot 2026-05-04 204254

Mamdani: NYPD did not coordinate with ICE, as leaders rally in Bushwick following violent protests, arrest

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices