Prosecutors seek 'special master' to review Giuliani items

Federal prosecutors have asked a judge to appoint a “special master” to review material seized by the FBI last week from Rudy Giuliani and ensure investigators aren’t able to see records protected by attorney-client privilege, according to court records unsealed Tuesday.

Associated Press

May 5, 2021, 10:55 AM

Updated 1,171 days ago

Share:

Prosecutors seek 'special master' to review Giuliani items
Federal prosecutors have asked a judge to appoint a “special master” to review material seized by the FBI last week from Rudy Giuliani and ensure investigators aren’t able to see records protected by attorney-client privilege, according to court records unsealed Tuesday.
In a letter dated Thursday, prosecutors requested the oversight, partially citing Giuliani's work as a lawyer for former President Donald Trump.
They noted it would be similar to what occurred after federal agents seized electronic devices three years ago from the home and office of Michael Cohen, who was also one of Trump's lawyers.
Cohen eventually pleaded guilty to campaign finance law violations and other crimes and was sentenced to three years in prison. After about a year in prison, he was released to home confinement as the threat of the coronavirus led to early release for some non-violent prisoners.
The federal probe is examining Giuliani’s interactions with Ukrainian figures and whether he violated a federal law that governs lobbying on behalf of foreign countries or entities.
Giuliani, a Republican and former mayor of New York City, has not been charged with a crime. He has said all of his activities in Ukraine were conducted on behalf of Trump. At the time, Giuliani was leading a campaign to press Ukraine for an investigation into Joe Biden and his son, Hunter, before Biden was elected president.
Last Wednesday, FBI agents recovered multiple electronic devices during an early-morning search of Giuliani’s home and office.
In their letter, prosecutors said the search was carried out on Giuliani by FBI agents who have not been involved in the investigation and will not be involved in the future.
They said in the letter to U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken a day after the searches that FBI technical specialists had begun extracting materials from the seized devices, but had not yet begun reviewing the materials.
Oetken permitted some redactions prior to the unsealing of the government's letter, including portions specifying what was taken from Giuliani and Washington lawyer Victoria Toensing, a former federal prosecutor and close ally of Giuliani and Trump. Her law firm said after the searches that she was told she was not a target of the investigation.
Oetken set up a schedule for filings pertaining to legal issues starting next week.
Giuliani has objected to the seizure in part because he contends the material on the devices would be subject to attorney-client privilege — the client being Trump. Courts sometimes designate an attorney not directly involved with the case, known as a special master, to address such concerns.
In more ordinary cases, a review of material seized from a lawyer might be conducted by a government “filter team” or a magistrate judge.
But they wrote that the government considered it appropriate to appoint an outside master in the Giuliani probe to determine what must be protected by attorney-client privilege in part because of “the overt and public nature of these warrants.”
They then quoted Judge Kimba Wood from the Cohen case when she stated that a master was appropriate for the “perception of fairness, not fairness itself.” Wood appointed a former Manhattan federal judge to conduct the oversight.
Citing a terrorist probe of a lawyer 20 years ago, prosecutors said a government “taint team” was commonly used but added that the appointment of a master may be appropriate when the attorney represents the U.S. president.
A lawyer for Giuliani did not immediately return a request for comment Tuesday. A spokesperson for prosecutors declined comment.


More from News 12
2:02
Subways and buses across NYC still running amid worldwide outage

Subways and buses across NYC still running amid worldwide outage

2:10
NYC airplanes grounded following global outage

NYC airplanes grounded following global outage

1:10
Widespread technology outage disrupts flights, banks, media outlets and companies around the world

Widespread technology outage disrupts flights, banks, media outlets and companies around the world

1:35
Sunny, warm and humid conditions heading into the weekend for Brooklyn

Sunny, warm and humid conditions heading into the weekend for Brooklyn

5:00
Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

2:09
Councilmember Zhuang speaks out following accusations of biting a police officer

Councilmember Zhuang speaks out following accusations of biting a police officer

13:51
'I’m not supposed to be here tonight.' Donald Trump recounts assassination attempt

'I’m not supposed to be here tonight.' Donald Trump recounts assassination attempt

1:22
National Weather Service says high rip current risk is in effect for NYC beaches

National Weather Service says high rip current risk is in effect for NYC beaches

2:00
Funeral service held for fallen NYPD recruit Edgar Ordonez

Funeral service held for fallen NYPD recruit Edgar Ordonez

0:29
Brooklyn DA: Man sentenced to 20 years for point-blank shots fired

Brooklyn DA: Man sentenced to 20 years for point-blank shots fired

1:33
NYPD data: Subway crime trending downwards citywide, but up in Brooklyn South

NYPD data: Subway crime trending downwards citywide, but up in Brooklyn South

1:49
Plans for new Tao Nightclub in Greenpoint met with community backlash

Plans for new Tao Nightclub in Greenpoint met with community backlash

0:37
Coney Island residents to vote on how new building developments will be funded, maintained

Coney Island residents to vote on how new building developments will be funded, maintained

2:10
Stretching matters over at StretchLab in Cobble Hill

Stretching matters over at StretchLab in Cobble Hill

0:26
Brooklyn pedicab driver pleads guilty for attempting to bribe a city inspector

Brooklyn pedicab driver pleads guilty for attempting to bribe a city inspector

2:07
NYPD: Councilwoman Susan Zhuang arrested, charged with felony assault at protest

NYPD: Councilwoman Susan Zhuang arrested, charged with felony assault at protest

0:20
President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID-19 while campaigning in Las Vegas

1:02
2024 has brought a years' worth of 90-degree heat to NYC

2024 has brought a years' worth of 90-degree heat to NYC

1:55
Mayor Eric Adams, Gov. Kathy Hochul say subway crime continues to decrease

Mayor Eric Adams, Gov. Kathy Hochul say subway crime continues to decrease

1:01
FDNY, law enforcement continues to investigate possibility of arson in Bushwick fire

FDNY, law enforcement continues to investigate possibility of arson in Bushwick fire