Rebuilding Brooklyn
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
Taking Action
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Killing of O’Shae Sibley leaves community shocked

Sibley was fatally stabbed at a Midwood gas station on Saturday, where police say that he and friends were dancing as they pumped fuel.

News 12 Staff

and

Adolfo Carrion

Aug 2, 2023, 6:36 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The death of O’Shae Sibley, who was stabbed to death at a gas station in Midwood on Saturday, has the community shocked and worried about safety and hateful rhetoric.  

Sibley, 28, was fatally stabbed at the station on Saturday, where police say he and friends were dancing as they pumped fuel. Police say a group of men approached them and began to shout homophobic slurs, which escalated to a violent confrontation in which Sibley was stabbed.  

Sources say that Sibley was a member of the LGBTQ+ community, and Brooklyn Community Pride Center member Omari Scott says his death is sending waves through the community.  

“Everything from verbal harassment to physical harassment, to actually being physically attacked, to murder,” said Scott. “It is deeply upsetting.” 

Dr. Nilar Thwin of Maimonides Medical Center’s LGBTQIA+ Mental Clinic works directly with the community and says she sees face fear on a daily basis.  

“I remember one girl telling me that she doesn’t want to go to certain neighborhoods, or certain places… because she said, ‘I can’t go with my girlfriend’,” said Thwin.  

Support has poured in, including from Beyonce’s website, which displays the message ‘Rest In Power, O’Shae Sibley’.  

Gov. Kathy Hochul told News 12 that this incident is being investigated as a hate crime.



More Stories

Top Stories

00:28
416Aetnamanarrest_2026-04-16-17-05-02

Man arrested for entering Aetna building with firearm

00:24
rihanICEupdate0416_2026-04-16-16-50-27

Bond hearing for Cheshire High School student arrested by ICE set for Monday

01:20
LD TODAY

Enjoy one more summer-like day before a more seasonable cool down

00:54
lockwoodexhibit0416_2026-04-16-16-50-16

Lockwood-Mathews Mansion Museum exhibit highlights Irish-American immigrant experience

00:59
416TONGTicketmaster_2026-04-16-16-45-40

Attorney General Tong weighs in on Ticketmaster and Live Nation lawsuit

00:16
0416FairfieldHouseFire_2026-04-16-11-37-35

Morning house fire quickly knocked down by Fairfield firefighters

02:31
Mark6aml416_2026-04-16-06-17-25

Monroe man and his son encounter whales while competing in World's Toughest Row

00:15
BPTAttack_2026-04-16-11-34-31

Victim hospitalized after late-night assault in Bridgeport

00:28
shelton

Police: Man facing drug charges following compliance inspection

00:43
stamfordarrest0414_2026-04-14-21-06-56

Police: Stamford officer facing charges in October crash now on administrative leave

00:56
Screenshot 2026-04-16 070049

Police chase across Putnam County ends with arrests of 2 Connecticut men

02:43
4162026CTrt_2026-04-16-05-25-23

Road Trip: Explore protected farmland in Southbury and hike along the banks of the Pomperaug River

00:54
Wright

Exclusive: Energy Secretary Chris Wright discusses the future of tri-state power, gas prices and the AI surge

00:58
WarTime416_2026-04-16-05-20-29

Senate again blocks effort to limit President Trump’s war powers in Iran

02:10
frankpkg0415_2026-04-15-21-18-09

Bridgeport Marshalls shut down amid fears of 'potential roof collapse'

02:52
415CravenICEdetentionfolo_2026-04-15-17-12-51

Judge orders bond hearing for CT teen detained by ICE

00:11
MTCTWestonFire0415_2026-04-15-21-33-21

Officials: 1 injured in Weston house fire

00:17
MTCTBridgeportMurder0415_2026-04-15-21-34-34

Bridgeport man convicted for fatally shooting man, stealing money from his body

02:39
rugby0415_2026-04-15-21-19-12

'What's the data behind this decision?' Petition started to save program after Quinnipiac Univ. eliminates D1 women's rugby

02:14
marissapkgrecut0415_2026-04-15-19-20-30_16-45-26,13

What’s next for SoNo distillery after developer gets initial OK for apartment plan

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices