Rebuilding Brooklyn
News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
Taking Action
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
LIRR latest

Police: 3 killed in fiery Bethpage car crash

Detectives say a 2022 Dodge Durango was driving east on Stymus Avenue near Carol Drive when it struck a tree and caught fire around 1 a.m.

Logan Crawford

and

Bob Doda

and

Lauren Pena

May 11, 2025, 8:05 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A fiery single-car crash early Sunday morning in Bethpage killed three people inside the vehicle, Nassau police say.

Detectives say a 2022 Dodge Durango was driving east on Stymus Avenue near Carol Drive when it struck a tree and caught fire around 1 a.m.

A neighbor told News 12 that she heard the crash.

"I ran, and all you could see is that car totaled, and it was just destroyed," said Angela Signoriello, of Bethpage.

Nassau police still had Plainview Road closed later in the morning, diverting traffic. It has since reopened.

Neighbors say the area near Plainview Road can be dangerous for drivers and that crashes happen too often.

"It's a blind turn. I've been involved in accidents because of it. Several of the residents have been involved in accidents because of it," said Chris Theo, of Bethpage.

Police have not named the three who were killed. The cause of the crash is under investigation.

Friends of the three victims were the scene Sunday, mourning their loss.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:57
bkbainbridgeflood530p521_2026-05-21-17-39-14

Bed-Stuy flooding sparks calls for storm drain, catch basin upgrades

01:45
F Umbrellacast

Rain ends as Brooklyn sets sight on a damp and cool Memorial Day Weekend

01:41
521MAMDANIFIFA_2026-05-21-12-58-10

NYC residents will get a shot at $50 World Cup tickets

01:29
KLNBWACOPEN0521530P_2026-05-21-18-09-56

Brooklyn Waterfront Artists Coalition hosts first in-person exhibition since 2025 Red Hook warehouse fire

01:54
willoughbyavedblshooting530pZC_2026-05-21-17-44-37

Two people injured in Bed-Stuy shooting

01:56
Marlborohousesimprovements530pZC_2026-05-21-17-51-28

Gravesend NYCHA complex breaks ground on new green space

00:53
KLNFULTONSTPARTIALCOLLAPSE52126830A_2026-05-21-12-00-53

Supermarket in Cypress Hill to remain closed after partial collapse

00:37
AP25167649344356

Joey Chestnut to defend hot dog eating title while on probation after pleading guilty to battery

00:35
TrumpdoesntsignAIorder0521_2026-05-21-16-43-18

Trump delays artificial intelligence order over concerns it could harm the AI industry

01:46
521edricnoon_2026-05-21-12-37-37

Overnight storms topple trees, leaves behind damage across Brooklyn

00:36
Fire truck generic

Firefighter, two civilians injured in Red Hook apartment blaze

01:53
521rebuildingbrooklyn_2026-05-21-06-50-39

Kensington streets get flood-fighting makeover led by trailblazing NYC engineer

02:06
rtdesert5spotnyCM_2026-05-20-22-59-18

Desert 5 Spot brings the Wild West to Williamsburg

01:37
myrtleave2ndalarmfireCM_2026-05-20-22-33-43

2-alarm fire in Bushwick injures 1 firefighter, displaces multiple tenants

kevingavinpleadeal1030pmCM_2026-04-24-22-39-07

Brooklyn serial killer sentenced to 30 years to life in prison for the murders of 3 elderly NYCHA residents

01:59
abandonedcarparkedforweeksCM_2026-05-20-22-47-35

Abandoned cars in Kensington raise concerns from homeowners

01:13
sackettststabbingUPDATE530pZC_2026-05-20-17-38-35

Stabbing inside Gowanus supportive housing building sparks safety concerns

02:01
disabilityprogramcutsCM_2026-05-20-22-18-10

Disability advocates warn Independence Care System closure could be ‘life‑changing’

02:07
KLNREMEMBERINGERYKACALDWELL0520530P_2026-05-20-17-53-27

Family and friends remember woman allegedly stabbed to death by boyfriend in Bushwick apartment

00:29
erinmerdysentencingthumb

Coney Island mother sentenced for drowning her 3 young children in the ocean

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices