Bronx man says he can’t sleep after NYPD mistakes him for murder suspect

The NYPD says they thought they were face to face with a murder suspect, thinking Martell was the man wanted for a homicide back on Dec. 22 but realized he was the wrong person.

News 12 Staff

Jan 27, 2022, 3:30 AM

Updated 812 days ago

Share:

A Bronx man says he can’t sleep, can’t talk on the phone and can’t even think straight after he says guns were stuck in his face and he was yelled at by people who ended up being police officers. 
Martell Niblack is a 34-year-old from Morissania with three kids and no criminal record. He says that Wednesday night, he was driving home from work and talking on the phone with his mom when, out of nowhere, his car was surrounded by unmarked vehicles and multiple people pointed guns at him. 
Martell says he thought he was being robbed. 
He says that as the men yelled at him to get out of the car, he dropped his phone. But it wasn’t until Martell got out of the car that he saw badges and realized he was being surrounded by police officers–who he says never, at any point, identified themselves as NYPD. 
He says he started to record what was happening on his phone and says he heard a call on the radio and the police started to back off and leave him alone. 
The NYPD says they thought they were face to face with a murder suspect, thinking Martell was the man wanted for a homicide back on Dec. 22 but realized he was the wrong person. 
The NYPD emphasized that Martel was never removed from his car, questioned, or taken into custody. 
Now, Martel filed a notice of claim, seeking $1 million. He and his mother say it’s not about the money, but about accountability. 
Martel tells News 12 that as the legal process plays out and he’s forced to relive the night over and over again, he’s looking forward to finding a therapist to help him try to clear his mind.


More from News 12
2:05
Police: 2 men wanted for stealing $2,000 from Bay Ridge store at gunpoint

Police: 2 men wanted for stealing $2,000 from Bay Ridge store at gunpoint

1:48
Dreary and gusty with cool temperatures for NYC; tracking rain for Friday night

Dreary and gusty with cool temperatures for NYC; tracking rain for Friday night

1:58
Explore the seasonal flora and fauna unique to Prospect Park in Brooklyn

Explore the seasonal flora and fauna unique to Prospect Park in Brooklyn

0:25
Police: Person of interest in custody following bomb squad investigation in Midwood

Police: Person of interest in custody following bomb squad investigation in Midwood

1:44
Dyker Heights elementary school students send letters and care packages to at-risk military veterans

Dyker Heights elementary school students send letters and care packages to at-risk military veterans

0:24
NYPD: Man walks into East Flatbush hospital, dies from gunshot wounds

NYPD: Man walks into East Flatbush hospital, dies from gunshot wounds

0:23
Man hospitalized following brutal stabbing in Brownsville, police say

Man hospitalized following brutal stabbing in Brownsville, police say

0:23
Spring Arrival: Hummingbirds heading to New York

Spring Arrival: Hummingbirds heading to New York

1:34
NYPD says new campaign has lowered crime citywide; some New Yorkers don’t buy it

NYPD says new campaign has lowered crime citywide; some New Yorkers don’t buy it

2:18
Landlord battling pancreatic cancer fighting to evict squatter

Landlord battling pancreatic cancer fighting to evict squatter

2:10
NYS Federation of Taxi Drivers offer $5,000 reward after string of carjackings and robberies

NYS Federation of Taxi Drivers offer $5,000 reward after string of carjackings and robberies

2:09
Federal civil rights complaint filed against NYC Public Schools Athletic League

Federal civil rights complaint filed against NYC Public Schools Athletic League

1:37
Affordable housing projects coming to Boerum Hill

Affordable housing projects coming to Boerum Hill

1:42
NY Road Runners announce new initiative with NYC Public Schools

NY Road Runners announce new initiative with NYC Public Schools

1:59
Police: Around $62,000 worth of jewelry stolen from 2 Williamsburg stores in separate incidents

Police: Around $62,000 worth of jewelry stolen from 2 Williamsburg stores in separate incidents

Police: Driver arrested in crash that killed 10-year-old girl in Williamsburg

Police: Driver arrested in crash that killed 10-year-old girl in Williamsburg

1:54
Brooklyn residents flock to Brooklyn Museum for pop-up 'Flower Flash'

Brooklyn residents flock to Brooklyn Museum for pop-up 'Flower Flash'

1:37
Parents fight to stop Visitation Academy in Bay Ridge from closing

Parents fight to stop Visitation Academy in Bay Ridge from closing

0:32
Group of parents launches coalition to deal with class sizes in New York City

Group of parents launches coalition to deal with class sizes in New York City

2:39
Man fatally shot in Mount Eden identified by police

Man fatally shot in Mount Eden identified by police