‘Like a scene from Criminal Minds’: Neighbors of Gilgo Beach killings suspect shocked by the arrest

Locals told News 12 that they are riveted by the new developments.

News 12 Staff

Jul 15, 2023, 9:48 PM

Updated 365 days ago

Share:

Neighbors of accused Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann have been left shocked by his arrest in the infamous cold case.
The 59-year-old was arrested in New York City on Thursday, more than a year after a police task force explored his possible connection to the crimes.
Prosecutors say DNA evidence and cellphone data point to the architect and father of two as a suspect in the murders of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.
Authorities say he is also the prime suspect in the 2007 disappearance and death of a fourth woman, Maureen Brainard-Barnes.
Heuermann’s house on 1st Avenue in Massapequa Park remains an active crime scene as law enforcement officials continue carrying out boxes filled with his belongings.
Locals told News 12 that they are riveted by the new developments.
“It looks like a scene from a movie like 'Criminal Minds.' It's right here. So crazy,” said resident Paige Pagano.
“He's some sick guy if it's true,” said Louise Colle.
Plainedge resident Juliana Hagmaier was 10 years old when the first body was unearthed along Ocean Parkway in 2010.
“I remember never being able to go to Gilgo because my parents were nervous,” she said.
Onlookers in Massapequa Park say they hope the arrest will give the victim’s families a long-awaited sense of closure.
“I'm just happy that there's finally going to be accountability and people are not just wondering who's next,” said Bay Shore resident Mayda Vargas.


More from News 12
3:24
FBI investigating Trump rally attack as potential act of domestic terrorism

FBI investigating Trump rally attack as potential act of domestic terrorism

2:13
HEAT ALERT: Hot and humid Monday in Brooklyn; feels-like temps near 100

HEAT ALERT: Hot and humid Monday in Brooklyn; feels-like temps near 100

1:54
Reps. Lawler, Torres to introduce bill enhancing Secret Service protection for presidential candidates

Reps. Lawler, Torres to introduce bill enhancing Secret Service protection for presidential candidates

2:07
A look back at US political violence that changed history

A look back at US political violence that changed history

4:10
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Trump rally attendee gives his eyewitness account of the shooting

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Trump rally attendee gives his eyewitness account of the shooting

2:37
Security increased at Trump Tower following rally shooting

Security increased at Trump Tower following rally shooting

2:27
Political analyst weighs in on gun violence in wake of Trump rally shooting

Political analyst weighs in on gun violence in wake of Trump rally shooting

1:29
Expert: Security will be a high level concern at presidential events in wake of Trump rally shooting

Expert: Security will be a high level concern at presidential events in wake of Trump rally shooting

1:34
Political analyst: Shooting at Trump rally will bring changes to 2024 Presidential Election

Political analyst: Shooting at Trump rally will bring changes to 2024 Presidential Election

0:28
NYPD: Suspect wanted for fatally shooting man in Bed-Stuy

NYPD: Suspect wanted for fatally shooting man in Bed-Stuy

1:22
2 cases of measles confirmed at Williamsburg Shelter

2 cases of measles confirmed at Williamsburg Shelter

1:48
Sunday service to resume at Brooklyn libraries

Sunday service to resume at Brooklyn libraries

2:03
Poll: More than 40% of women skip or delay medical screenings and appointments

Poll: More than 40% of women skip or delay medical screenings and appointments

2:11
Event calls for end for gun violence on anniversary of 2-year-old’s death

Event calls for end for gun violence on anniversary of 2-year-old’s death

0:38
Laura Kavanaugh to step down as FDNY commissioner

Laura Kavanaugh to step down as FDNY commissioner

1:25
37th annual Bedford Stuyvesant Volunteer Ambulance Corps block party renames street in honor of department founder

37th annual Bedford Stuyvesant Volunteer Ambulance Corps block party renames street in honor of department founder

0:25
NYPD: Woman struck by taxi in Park Slope; hospitalized in critical condition

NYPD: Woman struck by taxi in Park Slope; hospitalized in critical condition

0:40
NYPD: 21-year-old man fatally shot in Crown Heights; suspect faces multiple charges

NYPD: 21-year-old man fatally shot in Crown Heights; suspect faces multiple charges

1:09
Sunday service making a return to some NYC libraries this weekend

Sunday service making a return to some NYC libraries this weekend

1:37
Emergency management gives tips for NYC to prepare for hot temps

Emergency management gives tips for NYC to prepare for hot temps